Measuring Sustainability of Building Materials – A Call for Action (Published in Urban Infra World; Aug-Nov 2011)


Introduction

Growing population compounded with increasing affluence and affordability is exerting an unprecedented pressure on natural resources in India. The building industry is at the forefront of consumption of these resources. The construction industry has been growing at a CAGR of 13.3%[i]and this translates to a similar growth rate in consumption of building materials like cement, steel, bricks, stone, etc.
There is an urgent need of understanding the materials manufacturing industry and introducing sweeping reforms in the manner in which they are extracted, manufactured, used, recycled and disposed off. This article is essentially an introductory primer on the concept of “green materials” and the basis on which the “greenness” or sustainability of a building material could be measured.

Life cycle energy of materials

The concept of life cycle energy costs of building materials is something that is becoming a subject of interest for many scientists across the world. For long, the typical life cycle of materials has been considered to be a linear Cradle-to-Grave approach. The cycle would begin with extraction and end with the product being disposed off as waste.
The new and current thinking is a more cyclical Cradle-to-Cradle approach where the waste would then be converted to a resource for re-use in the same or another function. A typical example of such a process would be fly ash bricks. Fly ash is a waste product that comes out of combustion of coal in power plants. The disposal of fly ash was a nagging problem until the discovery that it could be used effectively to create lightweight and strong bricks and also could be added as pozzolana material in cement.

Embodied Energy

Life cycle energy or the embodied energy of a material is the sum-total of energy that is required for a particular material to be extracted, processed and brought to the site of application. The science of this documentation is still in its infancy. Measurement of embodied energy would have far reaching consequences in terms of helping the consumer make an informed decision on selecting a building material that would have the least embodied energy.

Typical Energy Usage types

Energy expended for various stages can be categorised as:
· Extraction Energy: The energy used for extraction of the material from its native source.
· Transportation Energy: The energy used for transportation that typically would happen between the location of extraction to the location of processing and then to the location of application.
· Processing Energy: The energy used for the processing of the raw material to the finished state.

Embodied Carbon

Embodied carbon is essentially a measure to estimate the effects of pollution that would be caused due to the extraction, transportation, processing and use of the material.
Exercises in measurements of embodied energy and embodied carbon have been undertaken in the west, particularly in United Kingdom. The University of Bath has developed an Inventory for Carbon and Energy (ICE). Further information on this system could be found the following website http://www.bath.ac.uk/mech-eng/sert/research/. In India, research organisations like the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore and a few other organisations have undertaken some pioneering work in this area.
Environmental Degradation
Extraction of material for various uses is the root cause of a majority of the environmental degradation we witness around the globe. This could be in the form of destruction of natural resources, depletion and / or extinction of wildlife, and destruction of natural wildlife habitats.

Social costs

It is the author’s firm belief that sustainability does not just stop with measurement of the abovementioned factors. Extraction of materials brings with it social upheaval, many a times, at the risk of complete eradication of the sole livelihoods of people living the area of extraction or processing. Extraction of minerals like Iron ore (for steel) and Bauxite (for aluminium) involves large-scale relocation of native populations as has been witnessed in the Chotta Nagpur plateau and its environs. Proper rehabilitation of these societies also needs to be carried out in order to reduce long-terms social inequity and damage.
In addition to the institution of an effective regulatory system that could monitor and audit the agencies involved in extraction, there must be a measure that could document the ‘social cost’ of a material. In such a manner, power is given to the consumers to make an informed choice on the material that they would purchase.

Need for concerted research efforts

Efforts in the green building industry have largely been based on reduction of operational resources of a building. Rating systems like GRIHA and LEED do not address enough the aspect of sustainable building materials. This is because there is very little data that is available on the ‘greenness’ sustainable materials.
There needs to be a concerted effort by all sections of the construction industry to understand and act upon the larger problem that we have at our hands as a country. The 2011 Census states that India has a population of 1.3 billion people. Considering that a large part of the population is still just below or above the poverty line, it is only logical to assume that further growth would put massive strain on the existing natural resources. This growth would be the cause for a degree and scale of environmental degradation that would not have been witnessed in the history of earth’s civilisation.
The way forward would involve the following steps:
1. Creation of a nodal coordination agency for research and policymaking. This would have representations from educational and research institutions, building industry, design, engineering and construction profession, contracting companies, mining industry etc.
2. Creation of a nationwide research policy and strategy.
3. Institution of scholarships and research grants.
4. Consolidation, review and analysis of data on a periodic basis and establishment of benchmarks.
5. Creation of a roadmap towards gradual phasing-in of these benchmarks into techno-legal regulations.
6. On the ground implementation of regulations.
An exercise of this kind demands the attention of all in the construction industry and a call for concerted action in this regard must be recognised at the earliest in order that we leave an earth that could be meaningfully enjoyed by succeeding generations.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My Neighbourhood

I step out onto the street. There are no pavements. Actually, the road hardly exists now. The BWSSB has dug up our road for the 5 th  time trying to the get the sewerage right this time. And prior to that, they were trying to get the water supply right. And prior to that? Oh well, they were laying the sewerage, only that the contractor wouldn’t listen when a few of us (architects residing in the area) told him that he was laying it much higher than what he should have done. Prior to that? They laid the sewer lines for the first time. Got us to close our well-functioning septic tanks to connect our building sewerage to the spanking new sewer line. Great work, you would think, just that they had no sewage treatment plant in the area. So, they connected it to the storm water drain by the side of our building. And prior to that, they had laid the water lines for the first time. Now, let’s talk about the electricity! A few months ago, they installed a new transformer. The contractor did...
Read more

Washing Green Linen in Public (Published in Smart Environs - Quarterly Musing of McD BERL, July-Sept 2010)

Green Buildings or Sustainable Buildings is the latest fad that all of us have caught on to. This is now being bandied about as the latest “it” thing to be done – by property developers, by home owners, by hotel operators, by hospitals, by industries and by anyone else who may have any connection with the building industry. As on date more than 40 Crores sft (400 Million Sft) is under Green Rating. As in any mass movement there is the complete spectrum of followers. On the one end are people who truly are passionate about the entire philosophy behind sustainability and on the other end are people who are just joining the bandwagon because it’s the “in” thing to do. In the absence of a well-researched and well-thought of mandatory system that defines what it means to be sustainable, numerous versions of sustainable practice have emerged. Along with a whole lot of good measures there are also some misconceptions of what Sustainability constitutes. If one were to go by modern definiti...
Read more

Flooring it the Indian Way

Flooring is a major feature that sets the mood of a home. The selection of the right kind of flooring involves thinking at multiple levels - the most important being the kind of aesthetic disposition that one has, besides durability, safety, hardiness, and the tactile feel of the floor. While imported marble, wooden floors and vitrified tiles are quite popular, there is a growing trend of using Indian marble, granite and other stones. Types of Indian Stones Stones available in India can be classified broadly into the following categories: 1). Marble; 2). Granite; 3). Sandstone; 4) Limestone; 5). Slates and Quartzite. Most stones go by the name of its source. Marble: Most marble comes from Rajasthan followed by Gujarat and Madhya Pradesh. The current varieties from Rajasthan include Rajnagar Marble and Abu Black. Gujarat produces a variety called Ambaji White while Madhya Pradesh yields the popular Katni marble. Granite: Most granite quarries are found in Tamil Nadu, A...
Read more